Hero Worship

Review by C.P. Champion

Buckley: The Life and the Revolution that Changed America. Sam Tanenhaus. Random House, 2025.

James Burnham: An Intellectual Biography. David T. Byrne. University of Illinois Press/Cornell University, 2025.

BILL BUCKLEY AND Jim Burnham were school friends of mine. They were pretend friends, to be sure. But when I cycled with real ones to Ambleside Beach or Lighthouse Park or up Cypress Mountain, or went cycle-camping on Saltspring and Galiano for the Duke of Edinburgh’s Award, or skiing at Whistler, or studied the Cambridge Latin after hours for credit, or on spring break, Buckley always came along. So absorbed was I in his writings and the energy field he projected that, as he might have put it, his ratiocinative ascendancy was osmotically infused into my juvenility. 

This alarmed some of my teachers. Mr. Krieger’s Groucho Marx eyes went as wide as saucers and his hairline receded two inches when, in Grade 10, I told him I was reading National Review and a novel about KGB penetration of U.S. media called The Spike by Arnaud de Borchgrave and Robert Moss. “My god. You’re too young. You should read something progressive,” he said, and gave me copies of two of his favourites, The Progressive and The Nation (in vain). 

Having taught us mediæval-renaissance history, art and architecture with a kind of Marxist tint (brilliantly if wrongly) and guided our school Europe trip, Mr. Krieger quit for a stint in union politics. Next I heard, after I graduated, he had been ousted in a BCTF coup and returned to teaching. I paid him a visit. The quality and behaviour of students (and their increasingly horrid parents) had fast deteriorated. He went off to guide baseball tours to Cuba. When I Google now, I see that Kit Krieger never gave up on politics (e.g., “Veteran educator Kit Krieger joins B.C. principals’ organization,” Vancouver Sun, May 27, 2012), and now pursues the Revolution high up in B.C.’s education bureaucracy. I wish him a speedy return to teaching and coach tours. 

When I read that Buckley’s famous friend Whittaker Chambers had renounced the Soviet atheist evil avowing that, in doing so, he was joining the losing side, it seemed to me wrong but romantic. Reagan’s “Star Wars” was roundly mocked by all detractors who said he would start a nuclear war (to wit, Mr. Krieger displayed a “Target Vancouver” antinuclear poster in his classroom), oblivious Reagan might actually win by bluff. I was a fortunate one, alive to the closing phase of the “struggle for the world” on clear battle lines. But like many I underestimated the extent to which the enemy would carry on the fight from within. Did the West really defeat the Communists or did the latter make the long march through the institutions. Look around; isn’t it obvious?

Not to everyone. Sam Tanenhaus’s encyclopaedic biography has a nice elegiac ending that pushes the liberal’s preferred view of conservatism: that no one knew what it was or is, or who the enemy was or is. I should have thought that was plain as the light of day. Buckley knew. Yet the biographer weaves a curious theme of uncertainty and equivocation throughout the story, as if it were all a muddle, Buckley a kind of Quixote and that, to the end, he failed to impose meaning and clarity on it all, dying a sad, ambivalent figure.

The note of failure comes in, for example, when he tells us that 1987 (the year I subscribed) was “a difficult year” for National Review. Buckley was planning to step down. I must admit my first few issues did have the air of being past their prime. Still the mystique clung and it was very heaven to get NR in the mail, relish “On the Right” at the back and again when collected in what Tanenhaus belittles as “nonbooks.” At home I found A Hymnal: The Controversial Arts which my father sportingly suggested we lend as a return favour to Mr. Krieger. (And he read it, his only comment being, with a twinkle in the eye, that when you read Buckley, you need to have a dictionary at hand.)


BUCKLEY'S "WEEK IN a life” books, Overdrive and Cruising Speed, I devoured thanks to the public library. I brandished Right Reason during my school’s daily compulsory 20-minute reading period (books only, no magazines allowed), and struck gold when I found The Unmaking of a Mayor in a used bookshop, the beginning of my near-complete collection. I read the spy novel, Stained Glass, and borrowed the audio book of Marco Polo, If You Can, languidly introduced by Buckley. The sailing narratives placed one spellbindingly at Buckley’s side, hand on the helm, shroud, sextant, or latest gadget aboard Cyrano or Sealestial in the middle of the Atlantic. (My actual lessons at Hollyburn Sailing Club were less thrilling, as I invariably got seasick and still do.) It wasn’t easy for me to catch “Firing Line” as the egregiously liberal KCTS 9 Seattle churlishly did not carry it. But spring break or Christmas in Maui meant that between reading High Jinx on the beach, visiting Haleakalā crater and Lahaina, and reading NR with early morning tea in Kihei, I could catch at least two episodes of “Firing Line” on PBS Hawaii on Sunday afternoons.

Taking up Tanenhaus’s biography I wondered what I would find that would be new. Mostly details like that the Buckleys married in Vancouver and honeymooned in Hawaii. Also that Buckley took up fiction-writing in 1978 from financial need (p. 793) which had never occurred to me. That as the middle child he had a fear of being overlooked somehow fits. That he got sixteen rosaries blessed by Pius XII and gave six to Irish maids at his boarding school. I must have forgotten that grandfather Buckley was a Texas sheriff (there’s a photograph).

And I laughed to learn that Buckley, at 19, cried to his mother on the telephone the day he arrived at Fort Bragg for basic training as a private. (I can attest to the shock to one accustomed to quite another life.) That the editor of the New York Times admitted that media coverage of Buckley’s 1965 no-hope mayoralty campaign was “distorted” was a surprise (p. 596). Less surprising was a Yale professor around 1950 calling Buckley “bigoted boy” and “philistine” (p. 237), the fine liberal art of name-calling. That the Buckleys bought their Connecticut house for $65,000 with help from “both sets of parents” was comforting to know. And I know the feeling Buckley had after the publication of McCarthy and His Enemies. Tanenhaus writes: “Only a naif might seriously suppose that ‘a book which reports the misreporting of the press should be fairly reported by the same press upon whose  misreporting it dwells’” (p. 277). That’s exactly how Canadian media treated Grave Error, which exposes their misreporting as does the sequel just published, Dead Wrong.


GROWING UP ON a long road that branched off Taylor Way, I became aware that it was named after Austin C. Taylor, Buckley’s father in law, who was involved somehow in developing early West Van. Reading Tanenhaus, I was horrified to learn that at Austin’s death in 1965, Patricia Taylor Buckley and her siblings’ inheritance amounted to $11 million but that after Canadian taxes she received $3 million. If Patricia and her two siblings each got one-third (Tanenhaus does not say), then Taylor’s estate may have provided 14% of Canada’s $14 million federal budget in 1965. Sam seems to think there is nothing wrong with that.

Not surprisingly, Tanenhaus offers little insight on Buckley’s religion except as a part of his childhood, which is how most liberals view Christian belief. But Buckley having lamented all his life the de facto replacement of the ancient Roman Rite of Mass (“Tridentine”) with a substitute called novus ordo missae (“new order”) that is so loosy-goosy that it acts as an enabler to what he called “liturgical disfigurations,” why was his funeral Mass (I have a xerox copy of the booklet from a friend who was among the 2,000 in attendance) conducted according to the novus ordo? I doubt it was Bill’s wish. Was the private Requiem that preceded it done in the vetus ordo? Tanenhaus offers no insight. In fact the biography has nothing to say about Buckley’s views on liturgy, a subject close to the man’s heart and I would have thought to some readers’ too.

The book also doesn’t ponder what I consider the most remarkable thing about Buckley — that had he chosen to do so he could have lived the life of an irresponsible playboy. I think of Buckley whenever I see “Blessed is the rich man that is found without blemish,” yearly in the Missal [actually more frequently than that, on certain saint's days, in the Divine Office, etc. —ed.], “that could have transgressed, and hath not transgressed: and could do evil things, and hath not done them.” Instead he chose a life of service to ideas and letters, multiplying the impact by playing the role of inspirational bon vivant and blithe warrior. 

To anyone who read and followed Buckley, especially anyone who felt bereaved when he died in 2008 as if he had been a beloved great uncle, Tanenhaus’ elegant biography could only be a let-down. It abruptly peters out after the 1970s on the basis, probably correct, that Buckley floruit 1960-1975 and, to Tanenhaus at least, was little more than a gadfly thereafter. It saddens me to read that it pained Buckley to sense his importance slipping. But that might just be Tanenhaus sticking the knife in.

As for his older contemporary and colleague James Burnham, when I first read him at 17 it seemed obvious that “liberalism is the ideology of Western suicide,” bringing about “the contraction of the West” in modern times, as he wrote in 1964 in Suicide of the West, of which my copy is a 1986 Regnery reprint from the Conservative Book Club. 

The author (aet. 17) reading National Review, on a canoe trip, Bowron Lake Park, B.C., Summer 1987. The Aug. 28 cover was headlined "Big Bad Bork." 


The Judge Bork hearings were a vivid tutelage in Democrat demonization of any competitor to the right, and some of my favourite National Review coverage. Revisiting Suicide of the West now, I see that Burnham wrote, “the liberals require an enemy on the Right.” In the 1950s, the “real” enemies being “beaten down or quiescent” they “invented McCarthy,” who as a public figure was largely a “liberal creation” (p. 219). But surely Senator McCarthy fired the first shot, demonizing the liberals?

Burnham, as David T. Byrne elaborates in this slimmer biography, would say yes, but it was according to plan. Both McCarthy and the liberals were victims of “communist tacticians” (p. 129) whose goal was to make “McCarthyism, not communism … America’s biggest threat.” By going overboard in his attacks on the red and the pink in positions of power, McCarthy stole the limelight, and liberal media and politicians, going berserk in turn, made the Senator, “a second-rate small-town politician” with “mostly third-rate” supporters, into a national bogeyman. 

The result was that a large slice of mainstream America came to believe McCarthy “the most dangerous man in American public life” rather than the fellow travellers and agents of the Soviet Union whom he rightly targeted. Somehow this seems to be the fate of all prominent figures on the Right, to be framed as worse than the obvious evils they oppose.

Byrne’s analysis is limited as he summarizes others’ assessments of Burnham and quotes reviews by Orwell, Arthur Schlesinger Jr., etc. of Burnham’s works. He says Orwell took his idea of two or three vast superstates in perpetual war in 1984 from Burnham’s Managerial Revolution. He says Burnham’s description of how future totalitarians would twist words gave Orwell the idea for “doublespeak.” 

Byrne’s criticism is more direct and blunt, whereas Tanenhaus pulls his punches. But neither is very illuminating. Indeed a more critical liberal analysis of the postwar American “Right” can be found in a book called Up From Communism: Conservative Odysseys in American Intellectual Development, by John P. Diggins, a study of political conversions from left to right published in 1975.

Buckley and Burnham were not able to stop history or prevent Western societies from moving left. Both men were Roman Catholics and Burnham reconciled before his death in 1987. In human terms they do, after all, appear to have been on the losing side, even if in supernatural terms the victory that matters most was won long before they were born. Because of this, and the liberals’ own ideological blinders, they remain more complex and compelling than their biographers let on.

Originally published in the print edition, Winter 2025, pp. 64-67.


← Older Post Newer Post →


Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published